Star Trek (2009)*****Great special FX, great sound, great filming -- but lacking a lot of story and actually some logic. Yes, I know it's a sci-fi movie, but when you blow up several cubic metres of "red matter" (which it only takes a drop of to turn a planet into a black hole) you expect a bit more than just a boom and a black hole. The Enterprise sits a few kilometers away watching calmly.
And how did a bunch of Starfleet cadets suddenly take over the bridge of the flagship? Impossible.
Oh, by the way, since this thread just doesn't seem to die, I'll make it a sticky

.